Reflected here is dummett s conviction that the concept of truth is of central importance both for the theory of meaning and for metaphysics. Mar 16, 2011 i would argue that in many if not most cases the true is the normative, or what hegel means by the spirit in human affairs. Sir michael anthony eardley dummett fba 19252011 was an english academic described as among the most significant british philosophers of the last century and a leading campaigner for racial tolerance and equality. Thought and reality hardcover michael dummett oxford. These are dizzying questions questions that compel us to think about the very essence of meaning, of logic, and ultimately, about the nature of truth itself. Michael dummetts three john dewey lecturesthe concept of truth, statements about the past, and the metaphysics of timewere delivered at columbia. When essays 1 and 2 appeared, it was an open question whether the tenses were best seen as operators or as contributing to the binding of temporal variables.
He was, until 1992, wykeham professor of logic at the university of oxford. Dummetts criticism of the context principle philip a. Dummett, truth and other enigmas philpapers this collection of michael dummett s philosophical essays, spanning more than twenty years, ranges in topic from time to the philosophy of mathematics, but is unified by a steady philosophical oother. Williams, with a reply by david wiggins a paperback edition of this book was published in 2000.
The essays are, in one way or another, informed by dummett s concern with metaphysical questions and his belief that the correct approach to them is via the theory of meaning. Dummett puts forward his controversial view of reality as indeterminate. Contributions to philosophy martinus nijhoff, dordrecht, 1987, pp. Truth and the past by michael dummett overdrive rakuten. Philosophy of mathematics 1991, it is dummetts chief contribution to frege scholarship. It may be difficult to see what his point is, or to take that point seriously, given that common sense. Deniers and defenders and the indispensability of the concept of truth. He wrote on the history of analytic philosophy, notably as an interpreter of frege, and made. Sir michael anthony eardley dummett fba 19252011 was an english academic described.
In the preface to the logical basis of metaphysics michael dummett says that. Bombs are raining down, destroying the cities of britain. Everyday low prices and free delivery on eligible orders. A japanese translation by tamon ishimura, under the title mugen, sono tetsugaku to sugaku, was published in 1996 tokyo.
Jan 04, 2012 these are dizzying questions questions that compel us to think about the very essence of meaning, of logic, and ultimately, about the nature of truth itself. This seems to require limiting meaningfulness to linguistic phenomena for which the question of truth or falsity is relevant. It is true, michael dummett recognizes that h s not intended to replace the. Introduction the past century has witnessed two types of philosophical debates over the concept of truth. Auxier and lewis edwin hahn volume 31 in the library of living philosophers. Coherence theories take truth to consist in relations of coherence among a set of beliefs. On the one hand, the controversy refers to questions about. Pdf thought and reality by michael dummett researchgate. Ebert university of stirling abstract this paper discusses michael dummetts criticism of the neofregean conception of the context principle. Truthconditional semantics holds that the meaning of a linguistic expression is a function of the conditions under which it would be true.
Thus we may speak of antirealism with respect to other minds, the past, the future. Dummett on the logical basis of metaphysics springerlink. Thought and reality is a lightly edited version of the gifford lectures that michael dummett gave at the university of st andrews during the academic year 199697. Michael dummett famously holds that the philosophy old and primrose pdf of thought must. Philosophy in the 20th century, especially in the anglosaxon world, has been dominated by the linguistic turn.
Gardiner, 1 book cesare cozzo, 1 book anat matar, 1 book darryl gunson, 1 book rivas monroy, ma. I will present four arguments by dummett that purport to show that the context principle is incompatible with platonism. Well, my interest in philosophy, and in particular analytic philosophy. In them he revisits some of the major themes that have preoccupied him over the course of his immensely distinguished career. Over 10 million scientific documents at your fingertips. Theories oftruth r a summary sketchl the object of this section is to sketch the main kinds of theories oftruth which have been proposed, and to indicate how they relate to each other. Michael dummett s three john dewey lecturesthe concept of truth, statements about the past, and the metaphysics of timewere delivered at columbia university in the spring of 2002.
Michael dummett frege held that truth and falsity are the references of sentences. The philosophy of michael dummett library of living. Robert brandom is a contemporary american analytic philosopher who synthesizes frege with kant and hegel by recognizing the true in talk about human affairs, such as justice and right, as a function of the normative in our language and practices. The philosophy of michael dummett library of living philosophers open court.
Open library is an initiative of the internet archive, a 501c3 nonprofit, building a digital library of internet sites and other cultural artifacts in digital form. Realism and antirealism the past three decades have seen a renewed interest among analytic philosophers in the topic of realism, an interest that has given rise to a significant body ofliterature at the intersection of metaphysics and the philosophy oflanguage. Revised and expanded, the lectures are presented here along with two new essays by dummett, truth. This applies not only to the area of analytic philosophy, but also to the intellectual world of continental philosophy. They were also michael dummetts questions, questions which, through the power of his thought and insight, he compelled many of us and certainly myself to think about as well.
I have been traveling for the past few days, and am sorry to be slow in noting the death of michael dummett, wykeham professor of logic at oxford from 19791992 and undeniably one of the most influential philosophers of the twentieth century. Dummett, michael 1978a, preface, in his truth and other enigmas cambridge, mass. On the other hand dummett is an analytic philosopher. He wrote on the history of analytic philosophy, most notably as an interpreter of frege, and has made original contributions to the subject, particularly in the philosophies of mathematics. Michael dummett s three john dewey lectures the concept of truth, statements about the past, and the metaphysics of time were delivered at columbia university in the spring of 2002. In this short, lucid, rich book, sir michael dummett, perhaps the most eminent living british philosopher, sets out his views about some of the deepest questions in philosophy. Litt 27 june 1925 27 december 2011 was, until 1992, wykeham professor of logic at the university of oxford. Thought and reality oxford, oxford university press, 2006. Truth and the past columbia themes in philosophy columbia university press. By john campbell michael dummetts investigation of a.
In seinem werk truth and other enigmas entwickelt dummett in auseinandersetzung mit klassischen realistischen. Philosophy of language has been highly influential. Philosophy of timeis an essential work of reference and is destined to be valued by philosophers of timeas well as those working in related areas of philosophy of science, philosophy of mind, and philosophy of religionas a vital research resource. Gergens social consensus theory of truth ii jonathan gormans coherence and pragmatic theory of truth iii michael dummetts naive empirical theory of truth iv mccullaghs correlation or critical theory of truth. Michael glanzberg 2008 stanford encyclopedia of philosophy.
Dec 30, 2011 but dummett s 19961997 gifford lectures, published in 2006 under the title thought and reality, suggest to me that moore is wrong in the passage quoted above to suggest that the realist cast of dummett s religious convictions were in any sort of tension with his antirealist view of meaning. Michael dummett was a philosopher and advocate for racial justice who worked extensively on issues related to immigration. Sentences cannot stand for propositions what frege calls thoughts, since the reference of a complex expression depends only on the reference of its parts. However, dummetts epistemological interpretation of the idea of. The concept of truth, statements about the past, and the metaphysics of time. Michael dummett s the logical basis of metaphysics should be a difficult book to read since it challenges the common sense of many people.
Oct 11, 2012 in reality of the past dummett attacks the attempt to use the systematic linkage between the truth values of statements uttered at different times to defend realism about the past. Dummett, michael truth and other enigmas free ebook download as pdf file. See all 5 formats and editions hide other formats and editions. Publisher, harvard university press, isbn, length, pages. But we might imagine it to be so long as to be unwieldy.
Truth pluralism, truth relativism and truth aptness. Buy truth and the past columbia themes in philosophy new ed by dummett, michael isbn. Dummett espoused semantic antirealism, a position suggesting that truth cannot serve as the. Michael dummett 1925 2011 menno lievers tells us about the ideas and life of an influential british philosopher. Michael dummett revised and expanded, the lectures are presented here along with two new essays by dummett, truth. Uxia, 1 book anthony appiah, 1 book roberto presilla, 1 book green, karen, 1 book enrico moriconi, 1 book barry taylor, 1 book kiyoshi chiba, 1 book beate rossler, 1 book. Michael dummett papers, 19562012, bulk 19822006 rbm 9526. Truth pluralism, truth relativism and truthaptness. This collection includes materials related to his academic interests in philosophy and voting procedures and to his personal passions for electoral reform and racial equality.
For example, suppose you ask me what it means to say that it is true that an oak tree stood here one million years ago. To the oxford handbook of truth michael glanzberg editor readers hold before them a volume under the title handbook of truth. Truth and other l dummett british journal for the philosophy of science 32 4 a defence of mctaggarts proof of the unreality. In truth and the past, dummett clarifies his current positions on the metaphysical issue of realism and the philosophy of language. Michael anthony eardley dummett the british academy. Michael john petry 1996 on there being nothing else to think, or want, or do in essays for david wiggins. Click download or read online button to truth and the past book pdf for free now. Download pdf truth and the past free online new books.
The objectivity of the past nordic pragmatism network. Routledge in the series the problems of philosophy. In truth and the past, dummett, best known as a proponent of antirealism, clarifies his current positions on the metaphysical issue of realism and the. The present collection of papers derives from a philosophy conference organised in the sicilian town of m ussomeli in september 1991. Michael dummetts investigation of a speakers grasp of meaning, the role that this.
Why almost everyone is wrong about the problems of. The fundamental notion for the account of the linguistic act of assertion of bsentences is, thus, that of the incorrectness of the assertion by making an assertion, a speaker rules out certain possibilities. Pdf the history of thinkers or the history of ideas. The philosophy of michael dummett edited by randall e. In bringing about the past michael dummett attempted to defend the coherence of the idea of bringing about the past. I agree that bringing about the past is conceptually no more problematic than bringing about the future, but argue, against dummett, that there is no need to restrict the scope of an agents knowledge in order to make sense of intentionally bringing about past events. The papers contained in this book, and dummetts replies, will, it is hoped, not merely offer a partial reconstruction of a philosophers life work, but provide an exciting and challenging vantage point from which to look at some of the main problems of contemporary philosophy. Subsequent sections will discuss some theories in detail. Michael dummett on antirealist theories of meaning date. Ted honderich a paperback edition, with corrections, was published in 1991. Michael dummetts the logical basis of metaphysics should be a difficult book to read since it challenges the common sense of many people.
I would argue that in many if not most cases the true is the normative, or what hegel means by the spirit in human affairs. The philosophy of michael dummett library of living philosophers. Dummett on meaning and truthconditions, to appear in the dummett volume in the library of living philosophers. Truth michael dummett frege held that truth and falsity are the references of sentences. The philosophy of timeis a new title in the routledge series, critical concepts in. I begin by endorsing dummetts argument that a truthconditional theory of.
A title like this suggests something very demanding. Sir michael dummett has, for over half a century, been among the most respected and provocative philosophical voices in the world. The philosophy of michael dummett library of living philosophers auxier, randall e. The metaphysics of time, the journal of philosophy, c, 1, jan. His groundbreaking and controversial work in epistemology, ontology, the philosophy.
218 1360 1500 1097 712 1004 1220 678 1276 1491 754 902 421 607 1375 1038 112 448 93 508 1074 744 880 627 70 953 889 232 818 1463